A Russian warship sails near Kamchatka in Russia’s Far East. Russia’s increased military expenditures have done little for its navy outside the Black Sea, and the consequences of the war have led to greater demands from Russian ships and their crews. (Shutterstock/Bboriss.67)
You Think the US Navy’s in Bad Shape? Look at the Russian Navy
Russian Navy vessels have increasingly been assigned to escort Russian “shadow fleet” tankers around the world—increasing maintenance burdens and probably hurting crew morale.
Much ink has been spilled in today’s press about the poor states of the US Navy and the Royal Navy, how both the United States and the United Kingdom have struggled to build ships and submarines on time and under budget, and how existing ships have confronted growing maintenance burdens. American and British defense planners can at least comfort themselves in knowing that their primary adversary in Europe—the Navy of the Russian Federation—is faring far worse.
Russia’s military budget has skyrocketed as a result of the Ukraine war, now accounting for around 35 percent of its total government spending and around 7.5 percent of its GDP. (For comparison, the US government spends about 13 percent of its budget on defense, or around 3.5 percent of GDP, although both numbers are far higher in the United States than Russia.) Of this money, most has been devoted to the land and air war against Ukraine; relatively little has gone to the Russian Navy, and of this, the lion’s share has been for the Black Sea Fleet, the only one of Russia’s naval forces actively involved in the Ukraine war.
As a result of these priorities, the Russian Navy’s warships are being pushed increasingly hard, and a combination of age and lack of proper maintenance facilities is taking its toll. Efforts to modernize and upgrade some of the Russian Navy’s once mighty vessels could be seen as wasted effort.
With the historically neutral nations of Finland and Sweden opting to join NATO after Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, the Baltic Sea is essentially an NATO-controlled lake, giving Russia limited access to the sea. NATO officials have estimated that the Russian Navy is outnumbered 10-to-1 in the Baltic Sea.
And the warships that the Kremlin can deploy aren’t just old; they’re being overworked as well.
Comparing the American, British, and Russian Navies
| Country | Russia | United Kingdom | United States |
| WDMMV True Value Rating (TvR) | 242.3 (World #3) | 88.3 (World #9) | 323.9 (World #1) |
| Personnel (Active Duty) | ~160,000 | ~32,400 | ~350,000 |
| Total Active Hulls | 283 (1 aircraft carrier, 17 amphibious assault ships, 207 warships + support ships, 58 submarines) | ~50 (2 aircraft carriers, 39 warships + support ships, 9 submarines) | 232 (11 aircraft carriers, 34 amphibious assault ships, 119 warships + support ships, 68 submarines) |
What’s Wrong with the Russian Navy?
Regardless of the navy, a sailor’s life is considered hard, demanding both physical stamina and mental resilience. Deployments can keep sailors away from home for months, and schedules can be grueling.
The US Navy’s warships—notably its high-profile aircraft carriers—have come home looking all the worse for wear. That has required lengthy maintenance periods, which in turn have led to longer deployments for other warships. Just this month, the Navy informed families of the sailors on the USS George H.W. Bush (CVN-77) that that warship likely won’t return home until sometime in early 2027, a full year after its departure. The UK’s Royal Navy is also a shell of its former self, and its maintenance schedules continue to run far behind schedule.
Yet the situation with the Russian Navy is arguably worse because its surface combatants are facing long missions of their own, without the resources to support them. Russia’s warships have been tasked with escorting and protecting Russia’s “shadow fleet” of sanctioned tankers, a NATO official told the Daily Mail this week. Instead of missions that show the flag and project might, it is a case of dilapidated warships protecting equally dilapidated tankers.
“Russia doesn’t really seem like a global navy anymore. They’re operating much closer to their own shores,” the anonymous official said.
This comes as Moscow has increasingly shifted away from deniability toward deploying naval vessels to waters such as the Baltic Sea, the Gulf of Finland, the Skagerrak strait at the entrance of the Baltic, and the English Channel. In February, Kremlin officials first vowed to deploy its navy to protect the tankers and other civilian ships from “Western piracy,” but that has only added to the strain.
“Their warships are being worked pretty close to death. They are past the point where they need to bring them back for repairs and modernization,” the official said. “I can’t imagine morale is very high on any Russian ships right now when they’re spending this much time at sea.”
As with the same issues facing the US Navy, the longer the deployment, the more maintenance is required. That is pushing the Russian Navy just as hard, and possibly harder, as the Kremlin hasn’t kept to tighter maintenance schedules.
The strain has been ongoing for several months, so it is unclear whether the Russian Navy is even capable of engaging NATO vessels if push came to shove. Russia has deployed the vessels as a means of deterrence, but it is outnumbered and outgunned.
Russia’s Navy Can’t Protect the “Shadow Fleet” and Prepare for War
In an effort to avoid the Western sanctions that were imposed after it launched its war against Ukraine in February 2022, Moscow has increasingly employed its so-called “shadow fleet,” also known as its “ghost fleet.”
The vessels routinely change their flags and sometimes their names—a practice The Guardian described as “flag-hopping,” whereby a ship rapidly and repeatedly changes the nation under which it is registered in order to throw off regulators.
In addition, the Shadow Fleet regularly employs invalid registrations in an attempt to escape tracking. Under maritime law, a ship is governed by the laws and regulations of the country whose flag it flies. Flag-hopping and invalid registrations are meant to bypass stricter environmental regulations and minimum wage standards for the crews. Russia has employed these and other techniques, including turning off and/or manipulating the ships’ Automatic Identification System (AIS) transponders to obscure tracking.
That hasn’t stopped NATO from seizing some ships, however—an act that the Kremlin described as piracy.
“We consider these acts as illegal, they border on international piracy,” Kremlin spokesperson Dmitry Peskov said in June after the UK’s Royal Navy and French Navy seized a Russian oil tanker. “Russia is taking measures to ensure the safety of its cargo.”
Russia had previously placed mercenary teams, including from the notorious Wagner Group, on shadow fleet vessels. The Kremlin’s military escorts may have been an attempt to get NATO to back down, but that could result in Moscow having fewer warships ready and available if it finds itself in a shooting war.
About the Author: Peter Suciu
Peter Suciu regularly writes about military hardware, firearms history, cybersecurity, politics, and international affairs. He has contributed to dozens of newspapers, magazines, and websites over a 30-year career in journalism, including Forbes and Clearance Jobs. He is based in Michigan. You can follow him on Twitter: @PeterSuciu. You can email the author at Editor@nationalinterest.org.
The post You Think the US Navy’s in Bad Shape? Look at the Russian Navy appeared first on The National Interest.