President Donald Trump speaks on stage at the Butler-Vandalia Student Activity Center in Vandalia, Ohio, during a campaign rally on October 3, 2026. President Trump now knows for certain that the American people oppose the Iran War; he should follow their lead, writes Will Walldorf. (Shutterstock/Dylan Hayes Photo)
Ending the Iran War Is Donald Trump’s Least Worst Option. Here’s Why.
Strategically, the Iran War was always a bad idea. Electorally, it is now clearly toxic for the Republican Party’s political fortunes.
President Donald Trump is reportedly considering a new round of strikes on Iran. The only trouble is that he already, in effect, asked the American people what they think of this policy during this month’s midterm elections. And for President Trump, the results were not pretty.
Voters strongly rebuked many of Trump’s policies, chief among them the Iran War. Sixty percent of voters said the war was the “wrong decision,” and 74 percent said it was a “crucial” or “major” factor in their vote.
These are eye-popping numbers given how rarely foreign policy plays a decisive role in recent US elections.
If Trump doesn’t want his presidency to go down as a complete disaster, he should back off from restarting the Iran War and work toward ending it instead.
History tells us this election outcome was likely to happen. That’s not because Americans have a knee-jerk aversion to presidents who call for sacrifice in times of war. President Woodrow Wilson rallied the public to stop the march of German autocracy across Europe and subsequently absorb the high costs of World War I, including tax increases, higher inflation, food and fuel rationing, and the loss of more than 100,000 US service members. Likewise, President Franklin Roosevelt’s call to defeat fascism garnered strong public support for World War II, which saw the deaths of over 400,000 American service members.
Trump’s problem is that Americans don’t buy his story because they understand Iran doesn’t present an existential threat. Some might say this is Trump’s fault, since he failed to sell the war before it began, barely mentioning Iran, for instance, in his State of the Union speech just days before launching the conflict. The problem runs deeper than that, though.
Even if Trump had mobilized public opinion before February, research shows his narrative still would have fallen flat because events on the ground didn’t line up. Instead of a powerful and belligerent country, Americans saw the opposite—a weak Iranian regime on the ropes facing severe economic problems and its biggest popular uprising since the 1979 Islamic Revolution.
Americans also never bought Trump’s line that a dangerous, nuclear-armed Iran is on the horizon. This isn’t surprising. After all, US intelligence assessments presented to Trump before the war said Iran was nowhere close to developing a nuclear bomb and had no intent to do so at that time. No wonder, then, that 55 percent of Americans saw Iran as a minor threat or no threat at all when the war started and 68 percent said in August that the war wasn’t worth its costs.
In a nutshell (and in sharp contrast to Wilson and Roosevelt), Trump started a war with no clear and achievable objectives that would benefit the United States. As he learned the hard way with the midterms, Americans get angry, question the competence of their leaders, and make them pay when costs from wars that lack this kind of purpose rise. History bears this out too.
As the costs of escalation in the Korean and Vietnam wars skyrocketed, Americans quit buying the Cold War “Domino Theory” logic and demanded to know why US soldiers were dying over tiny, insignificant pieces of land in Asia. Presidents Harry Truman and Lyndon Johnson, respectively, paid the price, opting not to run for reelection in the face of public disdain.
Similar to Trump with Iran, President Bill Clinton paid a high price for the 1993 debacle in Somalia. With the Cold War over and no strategic stake for the United States in Somalia, there was no grand purpose on which to buoy public support for military action. After 18 soldiers died in the Black Hawk Down incident, Clinton’s poll numbers plummeted, and Democrats faced historic midterm losses in 1994.
What should Trump do now? Simple. End the war in Iran. When the pain of Korea, Vietnam, and Somalia hit, Americans said they wanted out, and the presidents who started or dramatically escalated those wars complied.
For Trump, that begins by getting rid of sycophants, especially Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth, and letting pragmatists run the show. Trump needs to listen to and reward advisors who challenge his instincts, rather than ostracize them when he doesn’t like what they say.
Personnel changes are just the tip of the iceberg. Trump should bite the bullet and cut a deal that opens the Strait of Hormuz. Polls show Americans want good-faith negotiations with Tehran, even if Washington needs to make concessions.
It’s time for Trump to get over his obsession with superficial optics and listen to the American public. Otherwise, his presidency will go down as even more of a disaster than past wartime presidents, and Republicans will find themselves in a political desert where losing electoral ground is the norm, not the exception.
About the Author: William Walldorf
Will Walldorf is a professor in the Department of Politics and International Affairs at Wake Forest University. He is also a senior fellow at Defense Priorities, a think tank in Washington, DC. His latest book, To Shape Our World For Good: Master Narratives and Forceful Regime Change in United States Foreign Policy, 1900-2011 (Cornell University Press, 2019), explores how broad, public narratives drive major US foreign policy decisions about forceful regime change. His writing has appeared in The Chicago Tribune, Time, The Hill, The National Interest, Huffington Post, the Stimson Center, and Defense Priorities.
The post Ending the Iran War Is Donald Trump’s Least Worst Option. Here’s Why. appeared first on The National Interest.