Construction of the Mountain Valley Pipeline, an interstate natural gas pipeline, in West Virginia. Years-long reviews and lawsuits have driven up the cost of pipelines and power lines, and the Senate’s bipartisan bill would write predictability into law. (Shutterstock/Malachi Jacobs)
How the Senate Permitting Bill Follows the National Petroleum Council’s Blueprint
A bipartisan Senate permitting bill adopts the National Petroleum Council’s recommendations to rein in NEPA reviews, litigation delays, and state vetoes over interstate energy projects.
For the first time in a generation, the Senate has a comprehensive permitting bill that both parties wrote together and that the White House helped negotiate.
The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (S. 5653) is heading toward a Senate floor vote.
How Permitting Delays Raise Energy Costs
Over the past decade, natural gas demand climbed 49 percent, while pipeline capacity grew just 26 percentand deliverability from storage grew by about 2 percent. Electricity demand, after nearly two decades of little growth, is rising again as data centers, new factories, and the electrification of transportation and home heating place new demands on the grid. Because natural gas now powers much of that additional electricity, reliability and affordability depend on the infrastructure that moves energy—molecules and electrons—from production to consumers.
The average environmental impact statement for oil and gas pipelines, power generation, and transmission projects took four and a half years, over the last decade, to reach a permitting decision. Twenty-eight percentof major projects were sued. Agencies won about 80 percent of those cases on appeal, but court challenges commonly added one to two years, with appeals taking longer.
The Mountain Valley Pipeline was supposed to cost $3 billion; it ended up costing nearly $10 billion. Companies sometimes spend as much on permitting as on steel to build a pipeline. Every year of delay compounds financing costs, exposes projects to labor and material cost inflation, and lands on local families’ and businesses’ energy bills.
What the National Petroleum Council Recommends
Last year, at the request of Energy Secretary Chris Wright, the National Petroleum Council (NPC) convened more than 100 experts from over 40 organizations—industry, federal and state agencies, academics, tribal groups, environmental and public interest groups, financial institutions, and consumers—to diagnose the federal permitting system and recommend a path forward. Drawing on that participation, the NPC recommended a permitting system built on predictability, with rules written into law that outlast the officials who create them.
That consensus became Bottleneck to Breakthrough: A Permitting Blueprint to Build, released in December 2025, and the permitting bill now before the Senate aligns with it.
The bill addresses three key report recommendations:
- The purpose of the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) should be clarified. The NPC recommends that Congress clarify NEPA’s procedural nature and limit review to direct environmental impacts within the reviewing agency’s legal authority. NEPA would remain an important tool for informing agencies of environmental impacts, without becoming a barrier to building the energy infrastructure needed to serve the public.
- Judicial review should be streamlined and transparent. The NPC recommends Congress amend NEPA and all substantive environmental statutes to expedite permitting litigation and reduce uncertainty. The existing judicial framework for environmental permitting has become a significant source of delay, uncertainty, and inconsistency for critical infrastructure projects. Though designed to ensure informed decision-making, litigation under these laws has increasingly been used as a tool to obstruct rather than improve agency decisions. Reforms should clarify the scope, timing, and process of judicial review in environmental permitting cases, promoting both accountability and efficiency while preserving the opportunity for legal review.
- The Clean Water Act (CWA) should focus on clean water. The NPC recommends Congress amend Section 401 of the Clean Water Act to explicitly limit state water quality certification of federally permitted interstate energy projects to factors directly related to water quality. This ensures that state water quality concerns are met, as intended by the CWA, without letting certification become a state veto over interstate projects already approved under federal law.
How to Build a Modern Permitting System
The objective of the NPC study was to propose solutions within a Build-Protect-Engage framework:
- Build: Enable timely, responsible construction of energy infrastructure that serves national objectives.
- Protect: Ensure continued environmental and safety safeguards and risk mitigation through smarter, not slower, regulation.
- Engage: Sustain public participation and accountability through transparent, standardized processes.
A modern permitting framework must reconcile these three imperatives: to protect environmental and public safety interests, to engage the public in decisions that affect their communities, and to build infrastructure that meets urgent national needs. This is not a tradeoff, but a mandate to modernize permitting in a way that fulfills statutory intent while enabling responsible and timely progress.
Clarity, predictability, transparency, and accountability should replace the ambiguity, uncertainty, and inefficiency that characterize the current approach. Achieving this shift to a process that sets clear rules for infrastructure development, earns public trust, and provides long-term stability for developers will be challenging, but is a challenge worth undertaking.
About the Author: John M. Dabbar
John M. Dabbar is the executive director of the National Petroleum Council, a federal advisory committee to the Department of Energy. The NPC advises DOE on the oil and gas industries, including: Research, development, and demonstration to unleash American energy innovation; policy and regulation to enhance energy security, reliability, and affordability; market reforms to enhance the oil and gas industry; and industry and operator actions to strengthen energy reliability and security. With over 43 years of experience in the oil and gas industry, Mr. Dabbar has worked in upstream, midstream, downstream, pipeline projects and operations, crude and LNG shipping, offshore operations, international joint venture management, power systems for data centers, and government affairs.
The post How the Senate Permitting Bill Follows the National Petroleum Council’s Blueprint appeared first on The National Interest.